Sentinel Media records · public agendas and minutes, text only, refreshed nightly from each body's own site · not a newspaper

City of Rexburg

Council Minutes - December 17, 2025

minutes meeting date 2025-12-17 · fetched 2026-11-15 · 55974 characters · official file · plain text

1 
           (208) 359-3020 
35 North 1st East 
Rexburg, ID 83440 
Rexburg.org | Engage.Rexburg.org 
 
 
 
 
 
 
City Council Minutes – December 17, 2025  
 
Mayor Jerry Merrill 
Council Members: 
Bryanna Johnson    Eric Erickson 
David Reeser         Mikel Walker 
Colin Erickson           
 
 
City Staff: 
 
Spencer Rammell – City Attorney 
 
 
Matt Nielson – Finance Officer 
 
Keith Davidson – Public Works Director 
 
Alan Parkinson – Planning & Zoning Administrator  
 
Scott Johnson – Economic Development Director 
 
Deborah Lovejoy – City Clerk 
 
 
 
 
 
 
6:30 P.M.  
Council President Walker said the prayer.  
Council Member Johnson led the pledge. 
 
Roll Call of Council Members:  
Attending: Council Member Johnson, Council Member C. Erickson, Council Member E. 
Erickson, Council Member Reeser, Council Member Riggins, Council President Walker and 
Mayor Merrill.  
 
Mayor Merrill mentioned that tonight is Council President Walker’s last meeting attending as a 
councilmember. He said he appreciates all that Council President Walker has done for the city through 
his service as a councilmember as well as his service in the Emergency Services Department. Council 
President Walker has spent many years working as a paramedic and taking care of people. For all those 
years of dedication, the city thanks him for his service.   
 
Welcome New Employee: Anthony Magner – Golf Grounds Assistant Manager 
 
Anthony Magner explained that he has worked for the golf course for the previous five years as a 
seasonal employee. He said that he originally moved to Rexburg to attend BYU-Idaho 
University and started working at the golf course shortly after moving to Rexburg. He said he 
gradually fell in love with the work at the golf course and as a result, he changed his degree, his career 
goals, and many of his plans. He shared that he is excited to continue improving the golf course to make 
it one of the best in the area.  
 
Public Hearing 6:30 pm: Utility rate changes based on the Utility Rate Study by FCS, a 
member of the Bowman Group.  Designated as Resolution No 2025 – 13 if motion passes – 
Matt Nielson Action Item 
 
Finance Officer Nielson explained that the city typically proposed rate changes in July of each 
year to become effective at the beginning of the fiscal year, which starts October 1. However, the 
previous year the city had not changed the water and sewer rates because they were anticipating the 
results of a study. That study was only about 50% complete, even though the study indicated that if the 
rates were not changed mid-year, they would need to be increased more significantly in the next fiscal 
year, beginning the following October. As a result, the recommendation was to change the water and 
sewer rates at that time.  
 
Finance Officer Nielson noted that sanitation was not included in the changes. In October, 
sanitation rates increased, and the lighting fees were eliminated, which removed those charges from 
what users paid. Therefore, the proposed changes apply only to water and wastewater. The changes also 
affected the rates for Sugar City and the City of Teton because the city treats their wastewater.  
 
Finance Officer Nielson said the proposed increase for water is about 8 percent, with an 
anticipated additional increase of at least 6 percent the following October. The 8 percent increase 
becomes effective January 1. The proposed sewer rate increase is also an 8 percent increase, with 
another anticipated 8 percent increase the following October.

2 
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson asked for clarification regarding the water utility revenue requirement 
summary shown in the FCS Memorandum. He noted that the summary stated current revenue levels 
were sufficient to meet cash operating expenses and were keeping pace with annual cost increases, 
assuming a 2.15 percent annual growth rate. He questioned why, if revenues were projected to grow by 
approximately 2.5 percent, it was still necessary to increase rates by 8 percent.  
 
Finance Officer Nielson responded that the figures referenced only operating expenses. He clarified 
that for sewer utilities, the city needs to consider capital expenses, such as depreciation for asset 
replacement, as well as debt obligations. He noted that the city paid off the sewer bond in August of the 
previous year, which removed that obligation. The forecast discussed is a five-year forecast that 
accounted for depreciation of assets and approximately $60 million in capital improvements planned 
during that period. The intent is to implement gradual rate increases over time rather than waiting until 
large capital projects are completed and then imposing a much larger rate increase all at once.  
 
Council Member Riggins asked about a planned $33.7 million capital project and whether the 
proposed rate increases of 8 percent, followed by the proposed future increases, would be sufficient to 
cover those costs over the five-year period without requiring additional increases. He asked whether the 
city could rely on those projections without needing to return for further adjustments. Finance Officer 
Nielson explained that the projections were based on estimates, including inflation and wage growth, 
which could change from year to year. As a result, the financial model could be adjusted annually. It was 
also noted that when projects went out to bid, costs could be significantly higher than projected, and 
historically they were rarely lower. While changes were still possible, the city’s goal has been to keep any 
future adjustments small and manageable. 
  
Finance Officer Nielson further explained that the model assumed the city would take on additional 
debt during the five-year period to fund water and sewer improvements; however, on a positive note, 
some of the capital improvement projects could potentially be spread out over a longer timeframe, such 
as eight years instead of five, which could help reduce the rate of increases over time. He also 
mentioned that the city went through the rate-setting process every year, which allowed the financial 
model to be updated annually. If the projections turned out to be slightly off, adjustments could be 
made in either direction.   
 
Council Member C. Erickson asked whether the proposed percentage replaced the previous 
increase or is it added on. Finance Officer Nielson explained that the increase is cumulative and added 
to the existing rate. This means that each year’s increase is applied to the new adjusted rate. Council 
Member C. Erickson noted that this resulted in a significant overall increase over multiple years.

3 
Finance Officer Nielson explained that it is important to help citizens understand if rates are not 
adjusted gradually; the city could end up needing to ask voters to approve a bond levy to fund a large 
sewer project, which was generally unpopular. He said the financial model anticipates this issue, but for 
water and wastewater, debt was handled through judicial confirmation rather than property taxes. A 
judge approved the borrowing as ordinary and necessary, and the costs were paid through utility 
charges instead of additional property taxes.  
 
Council Member Johnson clarified that the estimates were partially based on population growth. If 
growth did not occur as anticipated, the projections could be adjusted.  Finance Officer Nielson added 
that growth assumptions helped generate additional revenue, which could help reduce the size of future 
rate increases.   
 
Council Member C. Erickson emphasized that the City Council’s intent is to help citizens 
understand that the city is trying to plan, save money, and spread the costs over time rather than 
imposing large increases all at once.  
 
Finance Officer Nielson further explained that water and sewer systems were especially challenging 
because expanding capacity is extremely expensive. Unlike sanitation services, which might only 
require adding a truck and driver, increasing sewer capacity typically requires multi-million-dollar 
investments. These costs tended to come in large increments rather than small, manageable amounts, 
which make long-term planning difficult, particularly for a growing city.  
 
Finance Officer Nielson mentioned that the city used capacity fees for water and sewer which are 
different from impact fees. When new development connects to the system, the city assesses the value of 
the existing system and collects fees based on the capacity used. Those funds were placed into reserves 
for future reconstruction. However, because fees were collected based on the current value of the 
systems, inflation often meant that reconstruction costs were higher by the time projects were 
undertaken. This process keeps costs fair so that existing ratepayers are not responsible for both the 
system capacity expansion and ongoing maintenance. 
 
Mayor Merrill opened the public hearing. 
 
Public Testimony in favor of the proposal (5-minute limit): NONE 
Public Testimony neutral to the proposal (5-minute limit):  
 
Eric Erickson asked whether the rate increase applies only to the City of Rexburg and not the City of 
Sugar City and Teton. Finance Officer Nielson made the following key points regarding the increases to 
the City of Sugar City and Teton:  
 
• 
The rate increase applies not only to Rexburg but also to Sugar City because Rexburg 
treats Sugar City’s wastewater.  
• 
Sugar City paid its proportionate share of all costs, calculated using an established formula.  
• 
Sugar City is subject to the same 8 percent rate increase and future increases for wastewater 
treatment.  
• 
Sugar City contributed to treatment costs, shared line and lift station expenses, and capital 
improvements, including a $9 million shared line reconstruction project.  
• 
Costs for shared infrastructure were divided based on usage, and increased capacity costs were 
shared as the system expanded for growth.  
• 
Sugar City currently has sufficient capacity, but when additional capacity is needed in the future, 
Sugar City would be required to pay 100 percent of that capacity increase.  
• 
If approved, the rate increase would raise Sugar City’s treatment costs, and Sugar City 
would determine how to manage its own internal sewer system expenses.  
• 
Rexburg’s responsibility is limited to the shared infrastructure up to Sugar City’s boundary; 
infrastructure beyond that point was not Rexburg’s responsibility.  
 
Mayor Merrill acknowledged that discussions with Sugar City and the City of Teton are often 
challenging due to rate increases but emphasized that all parties pay their share of the costs to maintain 
the system.  
 
Public Testimony opposed to the proposal (5-minute limit): NONE 
 
Mayor Merrill closed the public hearing.

4 
Council Member C. Erickson moved to approve Resolution No 2025 – 13 Utility rate 
changes based on the Utility Rate Study by FCS, a member of the Bowman Group; Council 
President Walker seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote: 
  
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
 
Public Comment: Items not on the agenda; limit 3 minutes; issues may be considered for 
discussion on a future agenda. Please keep comments on point and respectful.  
 
Items from Council: 
A. Committees: MEPI, Cultural Arts, Grants, School Board, MUSIC, MYAB, Emergency 
Services Board, Beautification, Trails/Parks & Recreation, Urban Renewal, Airport, Golf 
Board, ADA Oversight Board, Historical Preservation Committee, and Legacy Flight Museum 
 
Council Member Riggins reported that the Urban Renewal Agency did not meet this month; 
however, they are scheduled to meet in January.   
 
Council Member Reeser reported that the Legacy Flight Museum Committee did not meet. 
   
Council Member E. Erickson reported that the new pickleball courts at Smith Park are 
actively being used before the snow begins to fall. The use of the courts indicates they are a positive 
addition to the park.  
 
Council President Walker reported that the Mayor’s Youth Advisory Board helped with the Shop 
with a Cop event on Saturday and that there had been about 20 kids in attendance. He said the 
event went well. He also noted that the board is scheduled to hold its Christmas party the following day 
and that they would not meet again until January.  
 
Mayor Merrill noted that the Mayor’s Youth Advisory Board had the largest turnout of board 
members they have ever had to help with the Shop with a Cop event, along with many other volunteers. 
He thanked those who were able to attend and help. He also acknowledged the many community 
volunteers who participate each year, helping wrap presents and assist with other activities, 
and stated that the event was successful.  
  
Council Member Johnson reported a few updates related to trails. She said the committee met that 
week to discuss selecting the RFP for the design of a portion of the River Trail and the bridge, and that 
more information would be coming soon. She also stated that the committee met to discuss the 
survey that will be sent out regarding the new police station that the City Council discussed at 
the previous meeting. She said additional information on that topic is expected soon.  
 
Council Member C. Erickson added comments about the Shop with a Cop event and thanked 
everyone who assisted at the event. He said the McDonald’s crew appreciated the help they received 
serving breakfast. He added that cleanup had gone quickly and that it was always enjoyable to see the 
kids and officers shopping together. He then reported on school board activities, noting that there had 
been a lot happening in the schools. He encouraged citizens to check school calendars, as there had 
been many plays, sporting events, and other activities taking place, including basketball games, and 
suggested that people plan to attend these events. Regarding the Airport Board, he reported that they 
have not met and would meet again in January. He also provided an update from the Golf Board, 
explaining that after meeting with City Attorney Rammell and County Commissioner Brent Mendenhall 
he was informed that the Golf Board recommended not to proceed with the proposal to sell alcohol 
from a golf cart at the golf course.   
 
Council President Walker added that the eighth-grade girls basketball team had won the district 
championship, marking the first time in 28 years that the girls had won the title. Council Member C. 
Erickson noted that Rex Fullmer had been the coach during the previous championship win.  
 
Mayor Merrill added that he had recently attended his granddaughter’s fifth-grade orchestra concert 
and enjoyed seeing the students perform. He remarked on how impressive the improvements were from 
one grade to the next and noted that the older students were especially impressive. He expressed 
appreciation for the school programs and the many opportunities they provided for students to be 
involved.

5 
B. Other Reports: NONE 
 
Staff Reports:  
A. Finance: - Matt Nielson 
1. Financial Reports  
 
Finance Officer Nielson reviewed the Cash and Investment Balance Report. He noted that the 
balance would likely continue to decrease for another month because the city is approximately 99 
percent finished with all the journal entries required to close out the fiscal year. He stated that the city 
would then need to complete a year-end process and liquidate approximately $2 million, which would 
be returned to the Fire District. He added that a couple of million dollars were sent to the Fire District 
during the summer to provide them with sufficient cash flow to begin operations at the start of the fiscal 
year. After completing the year-end process, he indicated that the cash balance would drop by a few 
more million dollars. 
 
 
 
Finance Officer Nielson mentioned that in January the city would likely receive close to $3 million 
in property tax payments from the first round of collections, which would result in an increase in the 
cash balance. He explained that that pattern is consistent each year, as cash balances typically decline 
throughout the summer months, reaching their lowest point around January, then begin to increase 
again before declining once more as construction projects start. 
 
Finance Officer Nielson reviewed the Treasurer’s Expenditure Report: 
 
• 
The budget should be approximately 16.7% at this point of the fiscal year. 
• 
Certain funds were highlighted because they were being closed out and zeroed, requiring 
monthly adjustments due to reimbursements between the city and the fire district. 
• 
Park construction showed a significant variance (877%) due to the pickleball courts project 
being carried over from the prior fiscal year. 
• 
Approximately $265,000 was carried over to complete the pickleball courts, with a future 
budget adjustment planned. 
• 
The only capital project moving forward was the completion of the pickleball courts at Smith 
Park. 
• 
The courts are being heavily used, despite minor surface flaws. 
• 
The contractor agreed to return in warmer weather to fix the issues and apply an additional coat 
of paint. 
• 
The overall expenditure is at about 5.3% of the budget after the first two months.

6 
 
 
 
 
B. Public Works: - Keith Davison 
1. Approval of bids and budget adjustment for Teton River Park Construction Action 
Item 
 
Finance Officer Nielson explained that the Teton River Park South project had been included in the 
budget for several years. He reviewed the budget adjustment for that project and stated that the middle 
column of the report showed the proposed budget adjustment, while the far-right column reflected the 
total project budget. He noted that the city had anticipated paying for a portion of the project the 
previous summer, but that did not occur.

7 
Finance Officer Nielson stated that if the bid being presented is accepted, the project cost would be 
approximately $2.06 million. He proposed approving the budget adjustment which would increase the 
total project budget to $2.2 million. He explained that most of the additional funding would come from 
impact fees, noting that collections in the prior year exceeded forecasts and were carried forward. He 
also recommended increasing the urban renewal contribution by approximately $100,000, explaining 
that the project was originally estimated at about $1.6 million and that additional contributions are 
needed to complete the project. 
 
Finance Officer Nielson expressed confidence that the proposed funding plan would support the 
total project cost and provide a buffer for potential change orders. He added that if urban renewal did 
not approve the additional funding, the city could temporarily carry a negative fund balance and cover 
the shortfall in fiscal year 2027. He also noted that a grant of approximately $112,000 would cover the 
cost of trees and related work, which had been removed from the project budget. 
 
Council Member Johnson acknowledged that the project scope had been significantly reduced to 
control costs and that considerable time and effort has gone into redesigning the project and rebidding 
it. Mayor Merrill noted that the revised bid was approximately half of the original bid amount.  
 
Council President Walker moved to approve the low bid of $2,065,040. from BFC 
Diversified LLC and the budget adjustment for the Teton River Park South Project; Council 
Member C. Erickson seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote:  
 
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
 
2. Approval of Airport Consultant Contract Action Item 
 
Public Works Director Davidson reviewed the Airport Consultant Contract and emphasized the 
following points regarding the contract: 
 
• 
one-year, lump-sum contract to hire a consultant to assist with airport relocation, which would 
also require county commissioner approval. 
• 
The consultant’s role included securing land, coordinating with BLM, addressing grazing rights 
issues, identifying alternative sites, planning the transition to a new airport, and coordinating 
with current hangar owners. 
• 
Project costs would be shared 50/50 between the City and Madison County, with no federal 
funding applied to this contract. 
• 
Council Member C. Erickson emphasized the need for measurable progress and requested 
regular consultant progress reports every six to twelve months. 
• 
Grazing rights presented challenges with some potential properties, prompting the need to 
explore alternative land options. 
• 
The contract cost was fixed for the year but subject to annual review and approval. 
  
Council Member E. Erickson moved to approve the Airport Consultant Contract; Council 
Member Reeser seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote:  
 
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.

8 
Council President Walker asked whether the LID work has been fully completed. Public Works 
Director Davidson mentioned that all paving work has been completed and that crews are completing 
the finishing work on sidewalks and curbs. He explained that while most of the project is complete, there 
were still some remaining items, particularly related to landscaping. Some landscaping along First South 
had been torn up and was expected to remain in that condition due to upcoming development in the 
area, including new housing and apartment complexes. In other locations where landscaping had been 
disturbed, crews were expected to return to complete restoration work such as grass and other finishing 
details. 
 
Mayor’s Report/Business: 
 
Mayor Merrill reported that the Christmas Tree Lighting event was held on December 1 and it was 
well attended. He said they had installed software which tracked attendance and movement, it 
estimated that approximately 4,000 people were present. He noted that he was surprised by the turnout 
and expressed appreciation for the strong community participation. Attendees enjoyed activities such 
as visiting Santa, skating at the ice rink, and spending time together as families. 
 
Mayor Merrill also reported that he attended the Fire Department Christmas party, noting that it was 
always a positive event that highlighted the past year and helped build camaraderie and teamwork. He 
similarly commented on the City Hall Staff Christmas party, thanking those who attended and 
expressed his appreciation for the opportunity to gather with city employees. He concluded by noting 
that many activities were ongoing throughout the city and expressed pride in the community, 
emphasizing that many people were doing great work to support and strengthen the city. 
 
Items for Consideration: 
A. Review and approve updated Employee Policy Manual – Terri Hill Action Item  
 
HR Director Hill provided an overview of the updated Employee Policy Manual beginning with 
section 304.4 CERTIFICATION RAISE POLICY. She explained that the update would allow police 
lieutenants to be reviewed annually rather than every two years. She stated that this change was 
requested by the Police Department and would help address situations where supervisors could 
otherwise earn less than employees they supervise. She also noted that the Golf Professional position 
had been added to the list of employees receiving annual reviews. 
 
 
 
Further discussion focused on Section 1103.3 related to public information and communications. 
Council Member C. Erickson expressed concern about ensuring the Police Department would not be 
restricted from issuing timely public statements or updates. HR Director Hill invited legal counsel to 
provide clarification. City Attorney Rammell explained that adjustments have been made to preserve 
law enforcement discretion, particularly at critical incident scenes, and that certain language has been 
removed to avoid limiting police authority or compromising investigations. 
 
Council Member C. Erickson sought reassurance that police communications practices, including 
regular public updates, would not violate the policy. City Attorney Rammell confirmed that current 
practices were appropriate and that coordination between legal counsel and police leadership was 
already occurring. City Attorney Rammell noted that if future issues arise, the policy could be revisited 
and clarified.

9 
 
 
Mayor Merrill shared background information regarding the city’s emergency preparedness efforts. 
He explained that he regularly participated in monthly emergency operations meetings with 
representatives from the Fire Department, BYU–Idaho, amateur radio operators, and community 
emergency specialists. He emphasized that the city has organized emergency plans in place, including 
communication systems and trained personnel prepared to respond to various emergencies. 
 
HR Director Hill emphasized the importance of the City Council reviewing the city’s mission 
statement included in the updated Employee Policy Manual to ensure they were comfortable with the 
direction set by the employee committee, as the mission statement defined the core purpose of the city. 
She noted that a positive addition to the mission statement referenced to “America’s Family 
Community,” which staff believed aligned well with the city’s values. 
 
 
 
Council Member Johnson asked about a change in Section 304.4, which stated that employees 
could be eligible for certification raises at the discretion of the department head, and noted that the 
mayor has been removed from that language. HR Director Hill explained that, in several sections of the 
policy, references to the mayor have been removed based on recommendations from legal counsel. This 
change was intended to protect the city and clarify roles by giving department heads greater discretion 
and operational autonomy. In some cases, the term “the City” was substituted to make the language 
more general.  
 
HR Director Hill further clarified that although department heads were granted discretion to 
recommend certification raises, all pay changes still followed a formal approval process. Requests are 
entered electronically by the department head, reviewed by the Chief Finance Officer, then reviewed by 
the mayor, and finally processed by Human Resources before implementing. As a result, the mayor 
continued to review and approve all pay increases, including certification and merit raises. 
An additional safeguard existed through Appendix E of the policy manual, which listed approved 
certifications. Any new certifications must be approved by the City Council before being added to the 
handbook. The city has expanded recognized certifications to include SHRM, a nationally recognized 
human resources certification, in addition to the previously used public-sector-specific PSHRA 
certification. Certifications for the payroll clerk position have also been added. 
 
Council Member C. Erickson moved to approve the updated Employee Policy Manual; 
Council President Walker seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote:  
 
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
 
B. Planning & Zoning Recommendation to approve a Comprehensive Plan Map change 
from Low Residential (LR) to Intermediate Residential (IR) at approximately 301 S 12th 
W (25-01288).  Designated as Resolution No 2025 – 14 if the motion passes – Alan 
Parkinson Action Item

10 
P&Z Administrator Parkinson explained that the applicant approached the city to request a zone 
change; however, the zone being requested requires a change to the Comprehensive Plan to allow for 
the desired density.  
 
P&Z Administrator Parkinson reviewed the subject parcel on the map below. The property was 
identified as the Birch property, where Gem Prep School is planning to locate. The request applied to 
approximately six and one-half acres of property, which is proposed to be changed from low residential 
to intermediate residential zoning. That request was forwarded by the Planning and Zoning 
Commission for consideration. He stated that the City Council Members likely reviewed the minutes 
from the Planning and Zoning meeting held the previous night. Many of the same issues were discussed 
before, as the property has come before the City Council multiple times. He clarified that this is the 
fourth time the property has been considered for a zone change. 
 
 
 
Council Member Reeser questioned why the higher density zone designation appeared to stop at the 
subject property. He asked whether there had been any discussion during the Comprehensive Plan 
process about why the designation stopped at that location, especially since density appeared to 
continue south of the property.   
 
 
 
P&Z Administrator Parkinson responded that, at one time, the intermediate residential 
designation had extended all the way to Widdison Subdivision. During the Comprehensive Plan 
meetings, however, discussions led to a different outcome, as many participants felt that the zone 
designation did not fit the area at that time. As a result, the boundary was pulled back. He explained 
that the area had previously been designated that way but had since been changed. 
 
Council Member Reeser asked whether the concern had been that density should decrease closer to 
Main Street. P&Z Administrator Parkinson replied that the intent had been to protect the existing 
neighborhoods, noting that the Widdison Subdivision consisted primarily of one-acre lots and that 
nearby areas also included one-acre parcels. P&Z Administrator Parkinson said, when reviewing the 
map, the area now included a school, LDR-2 zoning behind it, and increasing densities overall. P&Z 
Administrator Parkinson also noted that Summerfield Subdivision, located across the road, already 
included LDR-3 and LDR-2 zoning and followed a similar development pattern. He explained that 
higher densities were typically placed adjacent to freeways to act as a buffer, because single-family

11 
development near freeways was more difficult to market. He added that the Widdison Subdivision 
began development in the 1970s and existed before Highway 20 was constructed. 
 
Council Member Johnson noted that the Comprehensive Plan had been updated only a few years 
earlier after extensive public input. She stated that residents had expressed a desire to keep that area 
low density and she feels uncomfortable changing the plan so soon after that effort. She added that the 
Comprehensive Plan defined intermediate residential areas as being close to services and expressed 
concern that the area lacked sidewalks, road shoulders, and safe pedestrian infrastructure, particularly 
for children. Based on those conditions, she believes that the intermediate residential designation did 
not fit the area. 
 
City Attorney Rammell asked Council Member Johnson whether she is referring to public input 
related to the recent meeting or to the Comprehensive Plan process itself. Council Member Johnson 
clarified that she was referring to the Comprehensive Plan process and reiterated that intermediate 
residential zoning did not fit the location. 
 
Council Member E. Erickson raised concerns about comparisons to Summerfield, noting that 
although parts of that area were zoned LDR-3, they did not appear to be built out at that density. P&Z 
Administrator Parkinson responded that Summerfield was a Planned Unit Development (PUD), which 
allowed flexibility in how density was distributed while maintaining overall density limits. P&Z 
Administrator Parkinson explained that townhomes had been placed in certain areas while single-
family homes were located elsewhere, all within the allowable density. 
 
Council Member E. Erickson continued to question whether a specific block of LDR-3 near Pioneer 
Road was developed at that density. P&Z Administrator Parkinson reiterated that the zoning and PUD 
had been approved together and allowed density to be shifted to accommodate open space and 
amenities, provided the overall density remained compliant. He stated that any future changes would 
require returning to the City Council for approval. 
 
Council Member Johnson added that, based on her experience living in Summerfield, there were 
only two sections of townhomes and that the remainder of the development consisted of unattached 
housing. P&Z Administrator Parkinson clarified that the townhomes had been built and sold several 
years earlier and that current sales involved unattached homes. Council Member Johnson emphasized 
that point to ensure residents understood the type of housing being developed. 
 
Council Member C. Erickson stated that the city had spent several years developing the 
Comprehensive Plan. He noted that comprehensive plans are difficult for cities to complete and 
emphasized that the plan is intended to guide future growth while preserving the community’s 
character. He stated that the subject property had been considered multiple times and adjusted to LDR-
2, which had been widely accepted. He expressed discomfort with changing the Comprehensive Plan 
again, especially after extensive public involvement, and stated that sufficient higher-density areas 
already existed within the city. He said that the Comprehensive Plan should remain unchanged unless 
new data or compelling information justified a revision. 
 
Mayor Merrill clarified the amount of land designated as LDR-1 compared to LDR-3. The city has a 
large amount of LDR-1 and LDR-2 land within the city limits and the impact area. He recalled staff 
previously stating that there were thousands of acres designated at those lower densities. He 
acknowledged the significant effort that had gone into developing the Comprehensive Plan. However, 
the Comprehensive Plan is intended to be a living document and not something permanently fixed 
without reevaluation. He stated that the city needed to continually assess its housing needs. He 
referenced comments made by Mr. Newkirk and others regarding the need for more diverse housing 
options, including what is often referred to as the “missing middle.” He said some Planning and Zoning 
Commissioners had shared experiences of their children being unable to live in the city due to a lack of 
affordable housing. He expressed agreement that while single-family homes were selling well, 
townhomes would likely sell just as well. 
 
Mayor Merrill explained that many objections to higher-density housing seemed to focus on quality 
of life, particularly traffic. He argued that single-family housing typically generated more traffic than 
town homes or multi-family housing. He emphasized that single-family households often included 
multiple drivers, including teenagers, resulting in frequent daily trips. By contrast, townhomes were 
often occupied by older residents or smaller households with fewer vehicle trips. 
 
Council Member Johnson responded by noting that these examples were anecdotal and emphasized 
the importance of relying on formal traffic studies rather than personal observations. 
 
Council Member Johnson referenced a city-conducted traffic study related to the Gem Prep School, 
which indicated that some intersections would operate at level-of-service D or E without improvements. 
She stated that she has not heard what mitigation actions were planned as development increased. She 
shared personal experiences of traffic congestion after school dismissal and expressed concern that the 
area has limited access routes. She also noted that the city did not receive grant funding for the

12 
proposed overpass study. The overpasses would have improved connectivity to the east side of the city. 
She emphasized the need for a timeline to address infrastructure issues before approving additional 
density. 
 
Mayor Merrill explained that intersections typically needed to reach levels of service D, E, or even F 
before qualifying for certain state and federal transportation grants. He stated that while this is 
unfortunate, funding is limited and prioritized for areas demonstrating the greatest need. He suggested 
that staff provide an update on discussions with the Idaho Transportation Department regarding the 
key intersection. He acknowledged that overpasses would not be built in the near term but emphasized 
that they remained part of the city’s long-term transportation plan. 
 
Council Member C. Erickson said many of the topics discussed at the Planning and Zoning 
meeting, such as comparisons to other developments and family demographics, were not directly 
relevant. He emphasized that the decision before the City Council is whether the proposed change 
meets the Comprehensive Plan’s criteria for increasing density to LDR-3. He stated that the area did not 
meet the plan’s standards for walkability, safety, or multimodal transportation, particularly given its 
proximity to the freeway and lack of pedestrian infrastructure. He concluded that the proposal did not 
align with the future growth vision outlined in the Comprehensive Plan and stated that he did not 
support changing the plan at this time. 
 
Mayor Merrill responded by questioning how infrastructure improvements could ever be achieved if 
developers willing to invest were consistently denied. He noted that the property has come forward 
multiple times for development using only single-family housing but that developers have been unable 
to make those projects financially viable due to the cost of infrastructure improvements. He added that 
this financial reality is one of the reasons the property continued to change hands and returned for 
reconsideration. 
 
City Attorney Rammell said to clarify the record, he referenced a recent comment made by Council 
Member C. Erickson regarding remarks from the previous Planning and Zoning meeting that may have 
seemed irrelevant. He explained that discussions surrounding Comprehensive Plan amendments often 
required a broader scope than typical zone change discussions. He noted that the Comprehensive Plan 
is evaluated against a wide range of factors, including consistency with planned goals, objectives, and 
desired future conditions. He stated that the Comprehensive Plan process involved consideration of 
seventeen different factors and is intentionally broad in scope. For that reason, He explained that he 
generally allowed more flexibility in discussion during Comprehensive Plan reviews and did not believe 
the comments made at the prior meeting were irrelevant. 
 
City Attorney Rammell asked a clarifying question regarding the reference to the time invested in 
developing the Comprehensive Plan. He asked whether this referred merely to the resources and effort 
expended, or to the actual goals, objectives, trends, and desired future conditions that resulted from the 
process. He emphasized the importance of clarifying this distinction for fairness to both the public and 
the applicant. Council Member C. Erickson responded that he is referring to the goals, trends, desired 
future conditions, and existing conditions identified throughout the entire city during the 
comprehensive planning process. Council Member C. Erickson stated that their concern was rooted in 
those outcomes rather than simply the amount of time or resources invested. City Attorney Rammell 
explained that he asked the question to ensure the position is not based solely on sunk costs or effort, 
but rather on the substance of the plan itself.  
 
Council Member Riggins stated that he saw three major issues. First, he explained that after 
reviewing the minutes from the Planning and Zoning meeting, he observed that the Planning and 
Zoning Commissioners themselves raised numerous questions. He noted that the commissioners 
emphasized that changes to the Comprehensive Plan should meet a high standard and repeatedly 
discussed the need to balance maintaining the integrity of the Comprehensive Plan with addressing 
housing needs. He further noted that the commissioners emphasized that any zone changes would still 
require additional review and compliance with city standards. 
 
Council Member Riggins said the second issue, which is based on his review; the proposal does not 
conform to the city’s Comprehensive Plan. He noted that the current low residential designation 
provided for certain transitions and standards, and he concluded that the request did not meet the 
criteria for approval. He stated that the proposal also failed to meet city standards related to the capacity 
of existing public streets and other required considerations, indicating that the city’s own approval 
standards were not being met. 
 
Council Member Riggins said the third issue is he believes the City Council is not adequately 
listening to one another or to the residents who would be directly affected by the decision. He 
emphasized the importance of considering public input from those living in the area. He referenced an 
email sent to P&Z Administrator Parkinson, noting that the writer acknowledged it might be time to 
assess development options for agricultural fields on the east side of South 12th West Street. He stated 
that the email suggested a coordinated plan that respected the rural residential character of the

13 
neighborhood while also improving traffic options. He referenced an email sent to P&Z Administrator 
Parkinson from Wanless Southwick. 
 
Council Member Riggins expressed uncertainty about whether the P&Z Commissioners fully 
understood the proposal and stated that, from his perspective, if he lived in the area, he would want to 
see visual representations showing how the development and roadway improvements would function. 
He suggested that the parties work through the issues and develop a plan that addresses those concerns 
before returning to the City Council for consideration.  
 
City Attorney Rammell clarified the record to ensure fairness to the applicant. He explained that, in 
land use cases involving Comprehensive Plan amendments or zone changes, applicants are specifically 
prohibited from providing detailed site plans or visual depictions. He stated that such designations 
attached to the land rather than the applicant, and that ownership could change after approval. For that 
reason, decisions could not be based on specific development concepts or illustrations. He emphasized 
that this process was not tied to a specific project design. 
 
Council Member E. Erickson explained that additional Comprehensive Plan changes are likely to 
come before the City Council soon. He emphasized that the city needs to be able to amend the 
Comprehensive Plan when necessary to guide development in appropriate areas. He noted that the 
subject property is bordered by RR-2 zoning to the north and RR-2 zoning to the south. He stated that 
whatever decision is made for this parcel would influence how the surrounding properties will develop.  
 
Council Member E. Erickson posed the question of whether the City Council wanted the entire area 
to develop into townhomes or into more detached, single-family dwellings. At the Planning and Zoning 
meeting an idea discussed briefly involved rezoning the entire property to LDR-2 instead of a 
combination of LDR-1 and LDR-3. He explained that this approach would allow for duplexes and twin 
homes while still being primarily composed of single-family dwellings on smaller lots. He expressed 
that this option felt more consistent with the surrounding area and raised concerns about extending 
townhome-style development along the entire corridor. He noted that higher-density development 
already existed on the opposite side of the freeway in the form of apartments. 
 
Council Member E. Erickson explained that LDR-2 provided a more appropriate buffer and that 
moving from LDR-2 to LDR-3 represented a significant increase in density. He stated that density 
would increase from approximately 60–68 possible units to roughly 110 units, nearly doubling the 
density. He said the proposal affected approximately six and one-half acres but noted that changing the 
entire property to LDR-3 would increase the total unit count by roughly 40 units. He stated that this 
represented a substantial increase and expressed that he would feel comfortable with a zone change to 
LDR-2 for the entire property. 
 
Council President Walker stated that he agreed with the position that LDR-3 is out of place at that 
location and felt that LDR-2 zoning would be more consistent with the area. 
 
Council Member Reeser asked for clarification about the difference in unit counts between the 
proposed zone and an alternative that retained LDR-2. P&Z Administrator Parkinson explained that the 
proposed LDR-2 and LDR-3 combination would allow approximately 105 to 110 units, while rezoning 
the property entirely to LDR-2 would result in approximately 30 fewer units, or around 80 units total.  
 
Council Member Johnson said the City Council is considering a Comprehensive Plan map change to 
intermediate residential. She explained that the intermediate residential designation included MR-1 
and MR-2 zoning classifications. She emphasized that the City Council needs to evaluate the 
Comprehensive Plan amendment itself, not the subsequent zone change. She stated that the 
appropriate question is whether MR-1 and MR-2 fit within that area, noting that those zoning types 
could be applied if the Comprehensive Plan is amended. She expressed concern that the decision could 
not be based solely on the developer’s stated intent to use LDR-3, because MR-1 and MR-2 would also 
be permitted under the proposed Comprehensive Plan change. 
 
Council Member Johnson further stated that, based on her own research using available records 
and her personal experience living near townhomes, only about ten percent of the townhomes in her 
neighborhood were owner-occupied, with the remainder being rentals. She emphasized that 
townhomes were not always owner-occupied. 
 
Mayor Merrill responded by acknowledging that townhomes are not always owner-occupied and 
agreed with that point. He then noted that, although the Comprehensive Plan change is being 
considered, any developer would still be required to come before the City Council for a zone change 
approval. 
 
Council Member Johnson replied that while a zone change would still be required, changing the 
Comprehensive Plan made it more difficult for the City Council to deny future requests. She explained 
that future applicants could argue that their proposals are consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, 
making denial more challenging.

14 
Mayor Merrill agreed that the City Council needs to be thoughtful about density decisions. He added 
that the City Council also needs to consider the overall mix of housing within the city. He stated that the 
city is experiencing an affordability challenge and noted that many young people could not afford to 
purchase single-family homes. He explained that townhomes and similar housing types could provide 
an entry point into homeownership. 
 
Council Member C. Erickson moved to deny a Comprehensive Plan Map change from Low 
Residential (LR) to Intermediate Residential (IR) at approximately 301 S 12th W; Council 
Member Johnson seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote:  
 
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
 
Mayor Merrill said the consideration for a Comprehensive Plan Map change from Low Residential 
(LR) to Intermediate Residential (IR) at approximately 301 S 12th W is denied and will go back to the 
Planning and Zoning Commission for a rehearing.  
 
City Attorney Rammell referenced the city code and explained that it is consistent with his initial 
understanding. He explained that the issue involved notice and public hearing requirements under city 
code. He cited Rexburg City Code Section 1.03.100(B), which stated that if the City Council rejected a 
Comprehensive Plan or zone change recommendation that originated from a Planning and Zoning 
public hearing, another public hearing is required. He also referenced subsection (C), which allowed the 
Planning and Zoning Commission to request an additional City Council hearing when needed and 
provided discretion to hold such a hearing. 
 
City Attorney Rammell explained that the city historically handled these situations either at the City 
Council level or by sending the matter back to the Planning and Zoning Commission, with the latter 
being the more typical practice. He said that returning the matter to Planning and Zoning functioned as 
the required public hearing and is his legal recommendation in this case. He explained that this 
approach is particularly appropriate because both the Comprehensive Plan amendment and the zone 
change are denied, which constituted a substantive deviation from the original recommendations. He 
emphasized that another public hearing is necessary to protect due process rights for both the applicant 
and members of the public. He added that it would be inappropriate to substantially alter the proposal 
without providing an opportunity for public input. 
 
Council Member E. Erickson asked for clarification, specifically whether denial of the 
Comprehensive Plan change required another public hearing on the same proposal. City Attorney 
Rammell explained that once notice requirements are met, the applicant could revise the application 
and submit a modified proposal, including a potential step-down in density, which could then be 
considered through the public hearing process. He added that while the City Council has discretion to 
hold a hearing itself, the city’s standard practice was to return the matter to the Planning and Zoning 
Commission. 
 
C. Planning & Zoning recommendation to approve a zone change from Low Density 
Residential 1 (LDR1) and Low Density Residential 2 (LDR2) to Low Density 
Residential 2 (LDR2) and Low Density Residential 3 (LDR3) at approximately 301 S 
12th W (25-01158).  Designated as Ordinance No 1341 if the motion passes and 
considered 1st read – Alan Parkinson Action Item 
 
Council Member E. Erickson moved to deny the zone change from Low Density 
Residential 1 (LDR1) and Low Density Residential 2 (LDR2) to Low Density Residential 2 
(LDR2) and Low Density Residential 3 (LDR3) at approximately 301 S 12th W; Council 
Member Reeser seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote:  
 
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker

15 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
D. Planning & Zoning recommendation to approve the Juniper Commons Plat located 
at approximately 810 Pioneer Rd, to subdivide the property into 55 lots (25-00999) – 
Alan Parkinson Action Item 
 
P&Z Administrator Parkinson explained that the property under discussion is located near the 
roundabout at 7th South and Yellowstone, close to Bodifi Gym. He stated that the plat being presented 
is a modification of a portion of an older plat that was previously known as Juniper Sands. He explained 
that part of the original plat remained built out, along with the parcel to the east of the road. He noted 
that the newly proposed lots shown on the plat would be developed as fourplexes. P&Z Administrator 
Parkinson said that the applicant provided all required information and that staff reviewed 
infrastructure, city code compliance, building plans, and the plat itself.  
 
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson asked whether sufficient parking is provided given the number of 
units proposed. P&Z Administrator Parkinson responded that each unit included two parking spaces. 
 
Council Member Johnson moved to approve the Juniper Commons Plat located at 
approximately 810 Pioneer Rd, to subdivide the property into 55 lots; Council President 
Walker seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote:  
 
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
 
Calendared Bills:  
A. Second Reading: Those items which have been first read: NONE 
B. Third Reading: Those items which have been second read: NONE 
 
Consent Calendar: The consent calendar includes items which require formal City Council  
action, however, they are typically routine or not of great controversy. Individual Council 
members may ask that any specific item be removed from the consent calendar for discussion

16 
in greater detail.  Explanatory information is included in the City Council’s agenda packet 
regarding these items.  
A. Minutes from December 3, 2025, Meeting - Action Item 
B. Approve Payment of the City of Rexburg Bills - Action Item 
 
Council President Walker moved to approve the Consent Calendar containing the minutes 
and city bills; Council Member E. Erickson seconded the motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a 
vote:  
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
 
Roll call vote to move into Executive Session as per Idaho State Statute §74-206(1)(f) 
To communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal ramifications of 
and legal options for pending litigation, or controversies not yet being litigated but imminently 
likely to be litigated - Action Item 
 
Council Member Riggins moved to enter into Executive Session as per Idaho State Statute 
§74-206(1)(f) To communicate with legal counsel for the public agency to discuss the legal 
ramifications of and legal options for pending litigation, or controversies not yet being 
litigated but imminently likely to be litigated; Council Member C. Erickson seconded the 
motion; Mayor Merrill asked for a vote:  
 
 
 
Those voting aye 
 
 
Those voting nay 
 
 
Council Member Johnson  
 
none 
 
 
Council Member C. Erickson  
 
 
Council Member E. Erickson 
 
 
Council Member Reeser 
 
 
Council Member Riggins 
 
 
Council President Walker 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
The motion carried.  
 
 
Executive Session Began 8:36 P.M. 
Executive Session Ended 9:11 P.M. 
 
 
Adjournment 9:12 P.M. 
 
 
 
                                                                                    APPROVED:  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
________________________________ 
                                                                                 Jerry Merrill, Mayor 
 
 
 
Attest: 
 
________________________________ 
Marianna Gonzalez, City Deputy Clerk

Text is extracted by machine from the official file linked on each page; the official file is the record. Sentinel Media, LLC.